Regions/countries/states/jurisdictions covered

ACT (Aus) (3) Africa (37) Alberta (5) Angola (3) Arkansas (6) Asia (1) Australia (50) Austria (6) Azerbaijan (1) Belgium (1) Benin (2) Bermuda (3) Botswana (6) Brazil (1) British Columbia (7) Burkina Faso (1) Burundi (1) California (5) Cambodia (1) Cameroon (1) Canada (119) China (3) Colorado (2) Congo (1) Czech Republic (1) Delaware (1) Denmark (10) Egypt (4) Europe (3) Fiji (1) Finland (7) Florida (7) France (10) Georgia (US) (4) Germany (15) Ghana (1) Guinea (5) Guinea-Bissau (3) Guyana (1) Idaho (2) Illinois (5) India (3) Indiana (1) Iowa (7) Ireland (3) Italy (1) Jamaica (1) Kansas (3) Kentucky (2) Kenya (4) Kyrgyzstan (1) Laos (1) Latin America (1) Lesotho (1) Louisiana (2) MIssouri (4) Maine (2) Malawi (2) Mali (3) Malta (2) Manitoba (8) Maryland (3) Michigan (12) Minnesota (1) Mississippi (2) Montana (1) Mozambique (2) NSW (Aus) (3) Nebraska (3) Netherlands (3) New Hampshire (1) New Jersey (2) New Mexico (2) New South Wales (2) New York (11) New Zealand (17) Niger (3) Nigeria (3) North Carolina (3) Norway (10) Nova Scotia (1) Ohio (5) Oklahoma (2) Ontario (55) Oregon (1) Papua New Guinea (1) Pennsylvania (3) Qatar (1) Quebec (7) Queensland (Aus) (1) Rwanda (2) Saskatchewan (4) Scotland (5) Senegal (2) Sierra Leone (4) Singapore (6) South Africa (6) South Australia (14) South Carolina (4) South Dakota (2) South Korea (3) Spain (1) Swaziland (1) Sweden (20) Switzerland (10) Tanzania (3) Tennessee (4) Texas (7) Togo (5) UAE (1) UK (38) USA (149) Uganda (18) Ukbekistan (1) Ukraine (1) Vermont (1) Victoria (Aus) (14) Virginia (2) Washington (State) (2) Western Australia (5) Wisconsin (3) Zimbabwe (5)
Showing posts with label guilty plea. Show all posts
Showing posts with label guilty plea. Show all posts

Wednesday, 27 July 2011

UK: The return of the "HIV Monster"

The British tabloid press had a field day yesterday following the sentencing of Nkosinati Mabanda, 44, at Wolverhampton Crown Court for 'reckless' HIV transmission. He received a four year prison sentence; was also given an anti-social behaviour order (ASBO) ordering him not to have sex without first revealing his HIV status (unclear if this also covers his time in prison); and will be considered for deportation following his release.

Of note, the only successful prosecutions for 'reckless' HIV transmission in England & Wales since 2004 have taken place when the defendant pleaded guilty.  (See this table of all UK cases from NAT - an additional heterosexual case in Wood Green, London, was dismissed in March 2011 due to lack of evidence).

In fact, Mr Mabanda had tried to change his guilty plea (and his legal representation) when he realised how difficult it was to prove the charges he'd already pleaded guilty to. He was not only unsuccessful, but did himself no favours by having a further sexual relationship with another woman (who did not test HIV-positive) in the two years he was out on bail.  (The first report of his case, from December 2009, is here.)

Since Mr Mabanda's country of birth is Zimbabwe (he apparently migrated to the UK in 2004), the two right-wing tabloids, The Sun and The Daily Mail pandered to their readers' prejudices and characterised this human being who had make mistakes (as human beings do) as an 'HIV Monster'.


The term "HIV Monster" and its variant, "HIV Avenger", has been around since the late-1980s. The idea that a person with HIV is no longer human but a "monster" was established by the myth of “Patient Zero,” a key figure in Randy Shilts’ bestselling 1987 book about the AIDS epidemic, And the Band Played On. "Patient Zero" was characterised as a sociopathic individual who may have intentionally infected others following his AIDS diagnosis, behaviour for which, Shilts suggested, the coercive powers of the state were ineffective. This myth has since been replayed many times worldwide and is often the impetus for calls for new HIV-specific laws and/or tougher sentencing.

Certainly, readers' comments suggest the tabloids did their job of dehumanising Mr Mabanda - many calling for his death, castration or, at the very least, immediate deportation to what they hope will be a certain and painful death in the absence of HIV treatment in his native Zimbabwe.  Anti-immigration (and anti-African) sentiment is also widely expressed.  The comment below is illustrative of all of the above, and yet also alludes to the difficulties of disclosure due to HIV stigma. (Of course, having children if you are HIV-positive is neither "off the cards" nor "selfish" - it is possible to conceive and give birth with minimal risk to a sexual partner or infant and many people with HIV can, and do, have children with the full support of their doctors, partners and families.)


The content of the stories - if not the tabloids' headlines –  take their facts and their moral tone from a police press release, and the words of the complainant.

The press release states:
Superintendent Jan Thomas-West, from West Midlands Police, said: "The particularly disturbing element of this case is Mabanda's blasé attitude towards his victim and his various other partners.

"Mabanda told officers that he had had sex with nine women in the UK and that seven of them had not know he was HIV positive. Unfortunately, these women were impossible to trace.

"He seems to have shown no regard for the health of others or the potential life sentence he may have passed on to anyone who had sex with him.

"His victim will remain on medication forever and her life expectancy has been reduced as a direct result of his actions.

"I am pleased that Mabanda has received a significant custodial sentence today."
West Midlands police subsequently circulated a second email quoting the complainant, parts of which were used in the The Sun and Mail stories.
Further to this release, please find below a statement from his victim, who wishes to remain anonymous:
"I am pleased with the sentence given to Mabanda today and that the judge recognised the seriousness of what he has done.

"I feel a combination of anger and relief. Anger at what he has done to me and potentially other women and relief because he has been punished for his actions.

"I think he should have been given life because that’s the sentence he has given to me.

"What he did has had a devastating impact and will affect me every day for the rest of my life, but now I want to move on.

"If anyone else recognises him because of the media coverage and they have been infected, they should go to the police and I will be there for them."
 The complainant also gave interviews to the local paper, The Express and Star and to BBC Radio 5.
She said: “He should have been given life because that’s the sentence he has given to me. He’s just scum. I hope he’s deported because I hate him.

“I’m on medication now for the rest of my life.”
And in the BBC interview she highlights that Mr Mabanda knew he was HIV-positive "before he came to this country."

I have a great deal of compassion for the complainant, who also admits in the BBC interview that she knew nothing about HIV (including, obviously, how to protect herself) before she discovered from Mr Mabanda's fiancée that she was at risk.  

But there appears to be no attempt to understand how Mr Mabanda acquired HIV himself; continued to have multiple concurrent relationships; and felt unable or unwilling to either use a condom or disclose to most of the women he encountered. (Interestingly, though, he had disclosed to two of the ten women.)  The only evidence of any kind of understanding of Mr Mabanda's issues comes from Twitter.




Couldn't agree more, Krystle.

Wednesday, 20 January 2010

UK: Scotsman pleads guilty to UK's first-ever charges for HIV exposure

A 41 year-old man from Scotland has pleaded guilty to four charges of culpable and reckless conduct after being accused of not disclosing his HIV status to four women between 2003 and 2008, only one of whom became HIV-positive. Although there have been almost 20 convictions for reckless HIV transmission in the UK since 2001 (of which only two were in Scotland), this is the first time that a conviction for HIV exposure following non-disclosure has been successfully prosecuted in the United Kingdom, although Scottish law has always allowed for this possibility.

The case of Mark Devereaux has been widedly reported in both Scottish and English media. While reports on BBC Online, the Scotsman, and STV.tv were somewhat neutral, tabloid coverage has been typically stigmatising, including today's Scottish Sun (Headline: "HIV fiend is lowest of the low" - inexplicably, he is named as Richard Devereaux in the article); Scottish Daily Record (which calls him a "callous predator"); and the UK-wide Daily Express (Headline: "HIV rat facing prison for infecting his lover').

Most of the articles focus on the fact that the 28 year-old woman who became HIV-positive was diagnosed during routine prenatal screening. She subsequently terminated the twins she was expecting with Devereaux. Some also refer to a fifth woman who was diagnosed alongside Devereaux in 1994. All of the articles rubbish Mr Devereaux's defence that he was in denial because the proseucution provide evidence that he was taking antiretrovirals - as if the two are incompatible!

BBC Online
also followed up its news story with a second report pubished today focusing on the reaction by the HIV sector, and specifically its concern that this conviction will lead to more arrests for non-disclosure without transmission in Scotland.

Deborah Jack, chief executive of the National Aids Trust (NAT), said: "It is totally unjust to single out people with an HIV diagnosis for punishment for unprotected sex - we all need to be wiser and safer, looking after ourselves and those we have sex with.

"Most HIV transmissions are from people who have never had an HIV test.

"We recommend that the Scottish Executive change the law so that people with HIV cannot be charged with culpable and reckless conduct if no transmission took place."

Roy Kilpatrick, chief executive of HIV Scotland, said: "We are particularly worried about the fact that prosecutions were brought in this case in respect of three sexual partners of Mr Devereaux who had not contracted HIV.

"We recognise that the primary motivation for bringing this prosecution must have been the actual transmission of HIV and that the prosecution would have felt it necessary to put the full context before the court.

"However, it would be alarming if the charges brought in this case open the door for future prosecutions in cases where no harm has been caused."

He said that bringing prosecutions where no harm had been caused would stigmatise people living with HIV.

Mr Kilpatrick called for a clear statement of Scottish prosecution policy.


Wednesday, 16 December 2009

Australia: Man gets 4 1/2 years for impossible HIV transmission

Update: December 16th
Wepukhulu Zebtek was sentenced to four-and-a-half years in prison by Judge Allan Fenbury who "said the sentence would deter other carriers of the HIV virus from not informing their sexual partners". Mr Zebtek will be eligible for parole in two years and three months.

Original post: October 19th
Something is very wrong with this picture. In January 2008, I reported that a Perth man, Wepukhulu Zebtek, now 44, had been charged with aggravated sexual penetration after allegedly raping a woman and apparently infecting her with HIV, but that his lawyer had successfully argued that since the woman had tested HIV-positive three days following the alleged rape, his client could not possibly have infected the woman, because it takes much longer than three days to form antibodies to HIV.

Today, the AAP reports that Mr Zebtek has pleaded guilty to causing grievous bodily harm after the charge of aggravated sexual penetration was finally dropped last month.

In other words, he has pleaded guilty to infecting a woman he couldn't have possibly infected, something that none of the various Australian news outlets, such as ABC news and Fox news mention.

In fact none the reports now mention that the sex they had was originally, allegedly non-consensual, but all the stories focus on the fact that Mr Zebtek didn't use a condom despite knowing he was HIV-positive. Only the AAP story also mentions that he didn't disclose before unprotected sex (which is an important element of the 'crime').

Obviously some deal has been done between his original arraignment and today's guilty plea, but I don't understand why Mr Zebtek would plead guilty to this charge, given the evidence that he couldn't possibly have infected the complainant.

I can only guess that it has something do with his previous history of unprotected sex, although this did not result in any criminal charges, according to the AAP story.

He had been counselled by the Victorian Department of Health in 2002 after a number of reports he was having unprotected sex with women other than his wife. Mr Sholz said Zebtek had denied the claims at the time but was given comprehensive and clear evidence about the risks of unprotected sex and was told he must practise safe sex. Victorian authorities closed his file after 2004 and Zebtek moved to W[estern] A[ustralia].
Mr Zebtek has been released on bail until his sentencing in December, when he faces up to ten years in prison.

Archive

Is this blog useful? Let me know

If you find this blog useful, please let me know, and if you find it really useful, please also consider making a small donation.

Thank you.

(Clicking on the Donate button above will take you to Paypal.)